Monday, September 15, 2014

How many clones do you need?


Today I listened to a Swedish gaming podcast, Viskningar från kryptan [Whispers from the Crypt], about a new old school game Svärd och Svartkonst [Sword and Sorcery]. Incidentally, this coincides with a new release of Delving Deeper being talked about. It's interesting, because I felt roughly the same level of interest in both of them. Let's begin by considering the older one.

As some of you might know, that latter game was once part of the train wreck that is Brave Halfling Publishing. But, after having been published by BHP, others have kept developing it, and now have a new version available.

When I heard about that, my first impulse was to groan and turn away. Buy that game? Again? But wait a minute. Haven't I done that before, and cheered my fortune almost every time?

Naturally, Delving Deeper has had a troubled road to walk to get to my door, but I don't think this apprehension about a new version of the game has that much to do with the troubles with the delivery of the last one. The fact that SoS didn't make me look forward that much to its release might be a clue to a general state of disinterest for new old school games, for me.

I have pdf copies of OD&D, LotFP first boxed set, Delving Deeper boxed set from BHP, Swords & Wizardry White Box Edition, Swords & Wizardry standard edition, Dragons At Dawn, Ambition & Avarice, Dark Dungeons, B/X and BECMI, AD&D1 and also multiple editions of T&T and other non-D&D old school games. Guess how many of those I have played? Why should I play them all? Are they all interesting enough on their own? I think most people have probably done like me, but mostly play or or two of them that best suit their taste and personality.

While this might be old news to most of my readers, I have not really had these thoughts sink in before. I've read a blog post about someone who really found one of the games mentioned above really great. I rushed out to buy it, and might have browsed it a bit before putting it on the shelf among the rest. Now suddenly I find myself with doubts. Why do I not at once become enthusiastic for these new game releases? I think I might have reached the point where I say I really don't need any more clones, or retro inspired games.

Since it feels like I have lost some enthusiasm, I'm planning on taking them out one by one and post my thoughts about it. If nothing else it might tell me what it was I found to enticing, and that I no longer can grasp.

Then again, I might already have Delving Deeper, but SoS? Maybe I should just buy, one more, and then call it quits...

3 comments:

  1. I'm with you. I've got so many games, mostly freebies, on my hard drive right now that I really just don't care much about any new retro-clones coming out, unless they're doing something really different than standard D&D fantasy. If it's elves and +1 swords and green dragons, I've got enough and don't really need another .pdf to read through just on the off chance that there might be a novel mechanic to add to my own Frankengame.

    Now, if there were some retro-clones or near clones with very different genres or settings, I'd be more likely to check them out. Non-medieval fantasy, sci-fi, etc. might catch my interest.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Care for some suggestions? :P

      * Arcana Rising (urban fantasy)
      * Arrows of Indra (pseudo-Indian)
      * Break!! (upcoming; greatly JRPG- and anime-inspired)
      * Hulks & Horrors (sci-fi hexploration and dungeon crawl)
      * Perdition (upcoming; fantasy world conquered by devils)
      * Spears of the Dawn (pseudo-African)
      * Stars Without Numbers (sci-fi)
      * The Final Castle (upcoming; somewhat JRPG-inspired)

      Delete
  2. The sad thing is, I have on almost all occasions been thinking "I should really run this new cool game!". And then nothing ever happened...

    While some of it related to the sucky situation with players in these parts, I feel some of them deserve some of my attention.

    ReplyDelete

Copyright 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016 Andreas Davour. All Rights Reserved. Powered by Blogger.